Do you need a fresh set of eyes to read through your manuscript?

~

It's really great the way you caught small yet significant details...  You got me hooked on your services.  I will be bugging you again!

Brad Metge

~

Would you like some feedback on your manuscript? Are you looking for a peer review or critique of your work? Would you like me to check for errors and suggest ways you can improve your story? 

With rates beginning at USD$33.00 for up to 3000 words (first impression critique), and a money-back guarantee, go ahead and give it a try!

My name is Elsa Neal and I'm a writer and linguistics student based in Melbourne, Australia, and I'm the Fiction Writing editor for BellaOnline. I have experience writing and proofreading for markets all over the world, and I have an eye for the differences between Australian, UK, and American English. I can help you rework your story for a global market.

 

~ I can't believe how helpful it is to have my work picked apart the way you've done it. What I learned from your critiques about my writing was just as valuable as the hundreds of dollars I spent on "How-To" books on writing. It's one thing to review the examples from real world examples of literature in those books, but it's entirely different and much more helpful to have the weaknesses of my own writing shown to me. I'm really glad I chose to use your service. Paul Perron ~  Elsa has critiqued many of my stories. She has a real eye for plot and character motivation and can see clearly when you've gone astray. Her grammar is spot on as well. Thanks to her, my story "The Rich People's School" recently appeared in the prestigious U.K. based literary magazine, Mslexia. I would highly recommend her.   Lauri Kubuitsile - author of the novella, The Fatal Payout (Macmillan 2005) ~

If you'd like to find out more about me, spend some time exploring my website. Start with my bio, my blog, and my articles and book reviews. Have a look at the example critique. I think that will tell you more about me than I can here. 

Bookmark this page to come back to if you think you would like to work with me.

What do you get from me?

More questions?

See an example critique

Privacy policy

~

I'm now offering critiques at two price levels: a "first impression" critique and a "detailed" critique. This is to allow you to get the assistance at the level you need, while working within your budget. Find out more.

For manuscripts longer than 10000 words, , together with a sample of approximately 1000 words. 

Alternatively, you may wish to start by sending me just the first chapter or two, which you can do using the order buttons below. 

This is useful for screening your manuscript for that initial submission to agents or publishers, who often don't want to see more than three chapters. I can help you refine your submission, and you can decide whether you want me to look at the rest of your manuscript. At this stage, I can give you a quote taking any previous payment into account.

~

Clicking on the following buttons will take you to the PayPal site. Please ensure that the URL you are directed to is a secure site (it should begin with "https" rather than "http", and you should see a padlock at the bottom of your browser.)

Not satisfied? Simply let me know and I'll refund your payment.

Critique of a work ~

shorter than 3000 words : 

First impression critique:	Detailed critique:
USD$ 33.00 AUD$ 35.00	USD$ 45.00 AUD$ 48.00

3001 to 5000 words : 

First impression critique:	Detailed critique:
USD$ 50.00 AUD$ 53.50	USD$ 70.00 AUD$ 75.00

5001 to 7000 words : 

First impression critique:	Detailed critique:
USD$ 63.00 AUD$ 67.50	USD$ 91.00 AUD$ 97.50

7001 to 10000 words : 

First impression critique:	Detailed critique:
USD$ 80.00 AUD$ 85.50	USD$ 120.00 AUD$ 128.50

Not satisfied? Simply let me know and I'll refund your payment.

Proofreading tips

Grammar tips

More articles for writers

~

Thank you so much for your peer critique... I really hadn't expected such a detailed response. I am immensely grateful to you for the good, solid advice you have given. You only had a small excerpt to work with, yet you understood perfectly the problem I'm having... I'm considering all the possibilities you suggested.

Your comments concerning the prologue are spot on and easily put right; yet I would never, never have seen it had you not pointed it out. Thanks.

You've given me a great deal to think about. And a lot to work on. It goes almost without saying, I should like to submit further excerpts and possibly the final draft in due course.

Michael Woods

~

Dear Elsa,

Your work was exactly what I needed and I really appreciate your quick reply. My only concern now is how I go about my revisions, or in fact a complete rewrite! But that’s my problem and you were expert enough to be thorough and cruel to be kind which is professional of you. I would like to send you future work if you will accept.

Your comments showed a thorough professional job where you thought a great deal about the story and how it can be improved. It was obvious that you did not just skimp over the words. You met my expectations for a thorough evaluation, your promptness of reply and considerate feedback. I would highly recommend you and hope to adjust my work to your standards. You may quote me as others should be encouraged to use your site. 

J Lucas

~

For a detailed course to help you brush up your writing skills, visit Jennifer Stewart's Write101 site.